Criteria for Choosing Cases for Mediation

Cost Issues

  • Desire to eliminate costly discovery and/or trial.
  • Expense to pursue may approach or exceed settlement value.
  • High stakes with risky outcomes.

Litigation Issues

  • Desire to avoid litigation.
  • Desire to organize and streamline litigation.
  • Desire to focus litigation.

Education Issues

  • Opposing counsel and/or client needs education.
  • Unrealistic expectations.

Negotiation Breakdown

  • Unclear how to proceed.
  • Deadlocked negotiations.

Communication Issues

  • Hostile or uncommunicative parties and/or counsel.
  • Emotionally charged issues and/or parties.

Flexibility

  • Willingness to re-evaluate liability and damages.
  • Willingness to go beyond last offer or demand.
  • Willingness to consider cost of continued litigation.

Time Issues

  • Desire to eliminate prolonged discovery and/or trial.
  • Dispute requires timely settlement.
  • Time delays affect settlement options.

Complexity Issues

  • Complex multiple issues.
  • Complex facts and /or mixed questions of facts and law.
  • Complex party issues - numbers, relationships between parties, internal problems within parties.

Relationship Issues

  • Interdependent parties.
  • Valuable to retain relationship.

Motivation to Settle

  • One party, or both, motivated to settle.
  • Party inclined to settle, doesn't want to appear weak.

External Factors

  • External factors and/or parties motivate, complicate, and/or control dispute
  • Necessity to avoid case precedent (or risk of setting precedent).